Greatest Aria?

Daniel Walden's picture
Submitted by Daniel Walden on Fri, 2006-10-13 12:54.

I'm just curious as to the opinions of my fellow opera-loving SOLOists regarding their favorite arias. Please do feel free to include the singer and the version, not just the song, as we all know how much of a difference that makes.

For me, it's a three-way tie between Maria Callas's "Vissi d'Arte," Giuseppe di Stefano's "Che Gelida Manina," and Mario Lanza's "Vesti la Giubba" (the one from The Great Caruso). All have so much raw emotion packed into them that anyone who can't resist their charms is, to my eyes, either a corpse or a Postmodernist. I do, however, have a special place in my heart for Lanza's short "Che Gelida Manina" clip, also from TGC, mostly due to grotesqure envy of that high C sharp. Here I am working to fill out my C and he comes along and one-ups me! I might actually be angry if I didn't damn near worship the man.


( categories: )

Maria Callas - 'Casta Diva',

Cafiero's picture

Maria Callas - 'Casta Diva', 'Ecco, respiro ancella

Ponselle - 'O nume tutelar', 'When I have sung my songs', 'Amuri, amuri', 'The nightengale and the Rose'

Caruso - 'una furtiva lagrima'

Tebaldi - 'Ave Maria' from Otello

Ruffo - 'Ah Pescator!', 'Allerta marinar'

Destinn - 'Tu, tu, tu!!'

Nilsson - 'Mild und leise'

Tom LoMonaco - 'Pagliaccio non so'

There are many more by each of these artists. Caruso and Tebaldi in those particular recordings are beyond this world.


Two more.

Peter Cresswell's picture

Two more favourites for my top three:

Wagner's 'Du Bist der Lenz,' sung by Gandula Janowicz

and

Puccini's 'E Lucevan le Stelle,' sung by Alfredo Coccoza.

;^)

Cheers, Peter Cresswell

* * * *

'NOT PC.'
**Setting Brushfires In People's Minds**

ORGANON ARCHITECTURE
**Integrating Architecture With Your Site**


Daniel, yes, they did a lot

JoeM's picture

Daniel, yes, they did a lot of that. But do you remember that particular one? I know it happened, but I don't remember where or when...and it's going to bug me all night now...


Looney Tunes

Daniel Walden's picture

They actually did a huge number of cartoons centered around classical pieces, and one of them may very well have had that aria in it somwhere. Most memorable among those cartoons, of course, was their absolute skewering of Herr Wagner; I'll never forget Elmer Fudd's "spear and magic helmet."


"La Spehhhhhheranca." Why

JoeM's picture

"La Spehhhhhheranca."

Why does that sound like something I heard on LOONEY TUNES? (Seriously, I think I heard that in a Bugs Bunny cartoon...anyone else know what I'm talking about?)


Ah ...

Lindsay Perigo's picture

One of Vince's. Must be PAL. I just watched & it's definitely running a tad fast. Spectacular top note, though, huh? Just nails it with the aspirate! "La SpeHHHHHHeranza." Naughty boy that he was. Smiling


Lanza video

Daniel Walden's picture

I saw it on YouTube right here.


Videos & half-tones

Lindsay Perigo's picture

Well, thankfully I still fall short of Linz's standards. And since when was that part of the deal? I don't recall reading anything about high C in any user agreement

Whaddaya think this is? Some kind of panty-waist place where people believe in rights, contracts & all the rest of that precious paraphernalia?!

P.S. It most definitely is a C sharp, or at least much closer to C sharp than to C. He sings the whole aria a half-step up from the normal in the TGC scene.

I can assure you it wasn't recorded that way. What he sang was a C, in the original key. In what format are you seeing it? All PAL videos run half a tone fast.

Linz


Oh dear

Daniel Walden's picture

Well, thankfully I still fall short of Linz's standards. And since when was that part of the deal? I don't recall reading anything about high C in any user agreement Sticking out tongue

P.S. It most definitely is a C sharp, or at least much closer to C sharp than to C. He sings the whole aria a half-step up from the normal in the TGC scene.


Daniel, if you're lucky,

JoeM's picture

Daniel, if you're lucky, you'll have neighbors who prevent the progression beyond b flat...


Daniel ...

Lindsay Perigo's picture

You don't have to get mad at Mario. That's only a High C, not C-sharp!! Maybe you have one of those videos that runs half a tone fast?! Actually, his 1949 commercial recording of Che Gelida is the best by anyone ever. It's my funeral piece. Well, one of them. And of course, Mario's E Lucevan is out of this world also. Along with the Vesti you mention. Callas' Vissi is right up there to be sure. As is Moffo's!

Linz

PS—Ask Cresswell how he arrived at the particular version of the Liebestod that he cites! Smiling

PPS—You do realise that if you achieve your High C you'll have to marry me? Maurone was spared this unhappy fate by failure to progress beyond B-Flat. Maybe you should quit at B-Natural? Smiling


Liebestod

Peter Cresswell's picture

Liebestod. 'Tristan and Isolde.' Leontyne Price.

But the other ones you mention aren't half bad either. Smiling

Cheers, Peter Cresswell

* * * *

'NOT PC.'
**Setting Brushfires In People's Minds**

ORGANON ARCHITECTURE
**Integrating Architecture With Your Site**


Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.