Rational passion and passionate reason
Who's Online
There are currently 1 user and 18 guests online.
Online users
Who's New
Linz's Mario Book—Updated!PollCan Trump Redeem Himself Following His Disgusting Capitulation to the Swamp on the Budget?
No (please elaborate)
0%
Yes (please elaborate)
56%
Maybe (please elaborate)
44%
Who cares? (My blood doesn't boil and I'm a waste of space)
0%
Total votes: 9
 Basic Economics by Thomas Sowell
 Economics In One Lesson by Henry Hazlitt
|
AC/DC Submitted by Joe Idoni on Sun, 2006-01-01 18:27
When talking to a person whose views are unintegrated, does one need to unintegrate to speak to them effectively? I only ask because I have a friend who is firmly entrenched in the christian cult of AA and I said I would talk to her about some problems that she has been having. These mainly reside with her complete inability to maintain a relationship for over a month and her complete lack of self-esteem. I know in my mind that these behaviors are all resultant from the same ideology, but I do not believe that it would be the most effective tactic for me to attack the whole thing in one go. In fact, I feel as though the only way to talk to her effectively about this situation is to pretend as if all her problems are unrelated. Is this right? Is there a better way that I am missing? Idoni
( categories: )
|
User loginNavigation
More SOLO Store  The Fountainhead by Ayn Rand
 Atlas Shrugged by Ayn Rand
Syndicate |
Pulled it off like twice in my whole life
Pulled it off like twice in my whole life. Not something I'd like doing on a regular basis.
It all basically comes back to fight or flight.
Ironic
The irony of this thread is that even had I wanted to give her dis-integrated information, I still couldn't. I gave the whole thing in relation to interpersonal relationships. I spanned the whole gamut from beginning to end.
Do you know what it's like explaining not just what altruism and socialism are, but what they mean?
Idoni
The whole truth
Idoni: Giving someone "the whole truth" does not imply giving them a reading of OPAR or the equivalent sort of detailed brain-dump. If you think the alternative in communicating or thinking is between a lecture series which gives the whole truth, and disintegrated out of context splinters... well that is very false and a very bad way to think that will lead you to a plethora of epistemological and moral problems.
Brandenology
Erik,
I don't really know that she could handle the full brunt of psycho-epistemology yet.
Besides, I don't even have it in my library!
Idoni
Hmmm...
Shayne,
Thank you for your response. I fear that either I am not representing the situation correctly or I am ignoring the truth. For the former, I cannot do as you suggest. Just as any life-reforming idea, I know that it must be instituted gradually versus completely. Therefore, to give her the whole truth would force her to shut down and not be able to process it fully. Such is the danger of living a life where one is inundated with a jumbled and ridiculous ideology.
For the latter, well, I should just smack myself and re-read my entire library because clearly I've confused myself on a major point.
But really, I appreciate it. I will take it into account when I talk to her today.
Idoni
Joe, would she be willing to
Joe, would she be willing to read something like "Honoring The Self" by Nathaniel Branden?
Be honest
Assuming you value the person, the best thing you can do is give your honest opinion. There are many ways this can vary to best get your message accross--the logical order, the tone, the level of abstraction and word choice, the emphasis and explanation of various things--but to deliberately disintegrate your thoughts because you think she can't handle them is manipulative and condescending. If you think so poorly of her that you think the only way to talk to her is not tell her the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, then you probably shouldn't be talking to her at all.
Take care in giving advice too. There's no shortcut to a person thinking and deciding for themselves what's best. The best you can do is help her to think through things; ultimately it has to be her own thoughts and conclusions that she relies on.