The total passion for the total height
 Basic Economics by Thomas Sowell
 Economics In One Lesson by Henry Hazlitt
|
Be Healthy or Else! Submitted by Ayn Rand Center on Mon, 2007-09-10 22:11
Ayn Rand Institute Press Release Be Healthy or Else! Irvine, CA--Under Democratic presidential contender John Edwards's "universal" health-care proposal, every American would be required to go to the doctor for preventive care in order to keep health-care costs down. In a similar proposal, a Tory panel in Britain suggested that, in order to control the spiraling costs of its socialized health-care system, Britons should be forced to adopt a government-prescribed "healthy lifestyle" or else be denied certain medical treatments. Britons who improve their health by, for example, quitting smoking or losing weight would receive "Health Miles" that could be used to purchase vegetables or pay for gym memberships. "These proposals are the reductio ad absurdum of nanny-state paternalism," said Dr. Yaron Brook, executive director of the Ayn Rand Institute. "According to these politicians, instead of having a government that protects our right to live our own lives, we are to be treated like incompetent children who need someone to force us to visit the doctor and eat our veggies. "Such proposals are the inevitable consequence of socialized medicine, where the only ways to control spiraling health-care costs are to cut benefits or attempt to reduce demand for medical services by forcing preventive care on individuals. Indeed, the fundamental justification for socialized medicine rests on the view that individuals are helpless to manage their own lives and so need beneficent bureaucrats to take care of them. Under socialized medicine, the government gives us 'free' health care--and in exchange, it gets to dictate how we live our lives. It's like a parent who tells his child, 'So long as I pay the bills, I make the rules!' "But coercing people into 'healthy' behavior is not only destructive to individual liberty--it's destructive to health. If an individual is to maintain his health and well-being, he must (in consultation with his doctor) make myriad judgments about what is good for his life and what is harmful, given the context of his knowledge, goals, and interests. When the government takes away the individual's freedom to pursue his well-being as he sees fit in favor of coercively enforced collective judgments about what is healthy or unhealthy, it prevents him from making such judgments and the life-promoting decisions they entail. It also leaves him at the mercy of any errors the government makes in its declarations about what is 'healthy.' Imagine the destructive consequences had people been forced to abide by the USDA's now widely discredited 'food pyramid.' "To protect our health and our freedom, we must reject socialized medicine in any form." ### ### ###
Copyright © 2007 Ayn Rand® Institute. All rights reserved. Op-eds, press releases and letters to the editor produced by the Ayn Rand Institute are submitted to hundreds of newspapers, radio stations and Web sites across the United States and abroad, and are made possible thanks to voluntary contributions. If you would like to help support ARI's efforts, please make an online contribution at http://www.aynrand.org/support.
( categories: )
|
User loginNavigation
 The Fountainhead by Ayn Rand
 Atlas Shrugged by Ayn Rand
Syndicate |
What
utter nonsense!
No wonder John Edwards' campaign is faltering and the British Conservatives are in a similar position, should Gordon Brown call a snap election next week.
The spiralling health care costs in America are due entirely to ambulance chaser lawyers like Mr Edwards suing hospitals and Doctors, causing a rise in liability insurance premiums, and that cost being passed on to customers.
In a similar proposal, a
In a similar proposal, a Tory panel in Britain suggested that, in order to control the spiraling costs of its socialized health-care system, Britons should be forced to adopt a government-prescribed "healthy lifestyle" or else be denied certain medical treatments.
See, I never thought they would actually come out and say it!
New idea: Release all Back Off! writing and material under GPL document license and encourage people in the US and UK to do the same.