Quote of the Day: Monopolies

Bravest Man in America's picture
Submitted by Bravest Man in ... on Sun, 2008-06-22 22:58.

A 'coercive monopoly' is a business concern that can set its prices and production policies independent of the market, with immunity from competition, from the law of supply and demand. An economy dominated by such monopolies would be rigid and stagnant.

"The necessary precondition of a coercive monopoly is closed entry—the barring of all competing producers from a given field. This can be accomplished only by an act of government intervention, in the form of special regulations, subsidies, or franchises. Without government assistance, it is impossible for a would-be monopolist to set and maintain his prices and production policies independent of the rest of the economy. For if he attempted to set his prices and production at a level that would yield profits to new entrants significantly above those available in other fields, competitors would be sure to invade his industry."

Ayn Rand


( categories: )

Reed

Mark Hubbard's picture

For self employed, or shareholder employees, then ACC is based on net profit (first group), or shareholder salaries. Drawings from the business are irrelevant.

Note you pay ACC on personal services, thus, if you tell them you are a sleeping partner, etc, (or run simply a rental business), then you can get out of the premium, however, if you work more than 30 hours  a week in the business then you are stuck with the premium, other than if you break the law of the land. If you work less than 30 hours, then you can be assessed on a part time basis, which means you will pay ACC on your net profit/shareholder salary. If no profit you won't pay. But again, if there is a profit, no way out of paying the premium, or if you work more than 30 hours a week, then you must cover at least the minimum premium.

Monopoly. You can't avoid it.

 

(Which is ironic when you then find out, as a self employed ACC payer, how hard it is to get a payout from them when you have an accident.) 


If you someone is not an

reed's picture

If someone is not an employee and only takes drawings do they have to pay ACC?

If not then ACC can be avoided in a way similar to avoiding my road toll.


ACC

Mark Hubbard's picture

ACC

 

[Ahem, yes, I'd forgotten that thread, or rather, my non-response to. Bookmarked it, but from Thursday I'm away for ten days, no Internet, so it might be after that. On the topic of that thread, I would urge you to check out the movie on the new thread I started - The Sea Inside. Same topic, quoting the Catholic Priest in the movie; 'God owns your body' Smiling We can discuss on my return.]


Mark - Can you give me any

reed's picture

Mark -
Can you give me any example of what you would consider a monopoly?

[Ahem]


Reed

Mark Hubbard's picture

Tell you what Reed, let us two pool our capital and set up a ferry service by sea, or perhaps even an airline. So long as we undercut what the landowner will charge to move across his land, then we've got a profitable venture. You could give your profits to the church, and I could drink mine Smiling


It would be simple for

reed's picture

It would be simple for someone to purchase a strip of land to isolate a peninsula from the mainland. The purchaser would then have a road access monopoly. In fact, any piece of land could be isolated by buying the surrounding land.

Without government assistance, it is possible for a would-be monopolist to set and maintain his prices independent of the rest of the economy.


Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.