Open-Source Objectivism?

Craig Ceely's picture
Submitted by Craig Ceely on Tue, 2012-07-03 13:28

You can do some serious study of Objectivism, free of charge, and I'm not talking about a 500 word column written by some twentysomething last week, but original audio and video materials by or featuring Ayn Rand herself, much of which was unavailable prior to the internet.

This it isn't quite open-source, of course, nor could we call it Objectivism Free University. You'll get no academic credit. You also can't download it or copy it (they do maintain their copyrights, and while they are probably not as litigious as Apple or the Rolling Stones, well, who the hell is?), but it's available online, for your use, free, thanks to the generosity of The Estate of Ayn Rand.

Why should you care? Well, as I mentioned above, some of this material has never been available before, and some of it is available nowhere else. You get Ayn Rand live and Ayn Rand responding to audience questions and answers. You also get to avoid the question of editing, which has dogged some of the publication of a few of these materials. And you can't argue with free.

So I've looked at their list of materials in The Ayn Rand Multimedia Library, and I've done a bit of rearranging here. My list, then, is not exactly the one you'll see at the Ayn Rand Multimedia Library page. I haven't listed most of the interviews, for one thing. I've put some of these items in rough chronological order, indicated which ones also feature a question and answer period, tried to clarify a thing or two, and I've added notes as to where else some of them have been published. If there's no indication of periodical or book publication, that means that I haven't been able to find it.

Early Days: 1961

Two interviews on video: Ayn Rand and the "New Intellectual," a classic, unavailable elsewhere, and "Capitalism vs. Communism."

"Faith and Force: The Destroyers of the Modern Word," long unavailable in printed form until its publication in Philosophy: Who Needs It. Includes Q&A session.

I think 1961 is an important year because as I see it, things began to change. Consider: Atlas Shrugged was published in October 1957, the Nathaniel Branden Institute geared up in early 1958, and For the New Intellectual was published in 1961. She also began her tradition of speaking at the Ford Hall Forum that year. Things were really starting to happen for Ayn Rand's ideas. The Objectivist Newsletter began publication in 1962, she began writing her column for the Los Angeles Times, and Who Is Ayn Rand? was published that year as well.

There was no internet back then, no cable television, no email, no Twitter. Not even cassette tapes. Her ideas were spreading by word of mouth, so by the standards of the day things were happening pretty rapidly. I have no memories of 1961 but I'm sure that Linz can tell you; we had to live in caves, when we were lucky enough to find one; fire had yet to be invented; life itself was black and white; and wheels were square. Yeah, we had it tough...

1962 and Later

The "Conflicts" of Men's Interests. Found in TON Aug 62 and in VOS.
The Esthetic Vacuum of Our Age, for some reason annoyingly retitled "Our Esthetic Vacuum." QA. Found in TON Nov 62.
The Objectivist Ethics. QA. Found in VOS.
Conservatism: An Obituary. QA. Found in CUI.
Philosophy: Who Needs It. QA. TARL III, 1974, and in PWNI. Yes, the classic 1974 appearance at West Point. Were the cadets really as impressed as we've been told? Listen, and judge for yourself.

Two from this list could also be legitimately placed on the Ford Hall Forum list, below:

1962 The Fascist New Frontier. TARC.
1981 (video) The Sanction of the Victims, from November 1981, Ayn Rand's last public appearance. Leonard Peikoff read the same talk at the Ford Hall Forum the following spring. Includes QA. Found in VOR.

Ford Hall Forum

1961 The Intellectual Bankruptcy of Our Age. QA. VOR.
America's Persecuted Minority: Big Business. QA. CUI.

Note the title here: this one is often misquoted by those attacking Rand as "America's Most Persecuted Minority."

1962 The Fascist New Frontier. ARI places it in their previous list.

1964 Is Atlas Shrugging? TON Aug 64 and CUI.

1965 The New Fascism: Rule by Consensus TON May-June 65 and CUI

1966 Our Cultural Value-Deprivation TO Apr 66 and VOR

1967 What Is Capitalism?

This is a version of the item by the same name in TON Nov-Dec 65 and in CUI.

1967 The Wreckage of the Consensus TO Apr-May 67 and CUI

1968 Of Living Death. QA. TO Sep-Nov 68 and VOR.

1969 Apollo and Dionysus. QA. TO Dec 69-Jan 70 and RP.

1971 The Moratorium on Brains. TARL I

1972 A Nation's Unity. QA. TARL II

1973 Censorship: Local and Express. QA. TARL III and PWNI.

1974 Egalitarianism and Inflation. QA. TARL IV and PWNI.

1976 The Moral Factor. QA

1977 Global Balkanization. QA. RP.

1978 Cultural Update. QA.

1981 The Age of Mediocrity. QA.

1981 (Video) The Sanction of the Victims. QA. Delivered in New Orleans, Nov 81. VOR.

A couple of notes: Since I'm presenting this as an opportunity for study, please note that Harry Binswanger's The Ayn Rand Lexicon: Objectivism from A to Z is also available from the same source, free, and online. Also, the three Ayn Rand periodicals -- The Objectivist Newsletter, The Objectivist, and The Ayn Rand Letter are available as a package, and that's how I've listed them in the links, primarily because the individual volumes are occasionally out of stock.

Key:

CUI: Capitalism: The Unknown Ideal
PWNI: Philosophy: Who Needs It
RP: Return of the Primitive
TARC: The Ayn Rand Column
TARL: The Ayn Rand Letter
TO: The Objectivist
TON: The Objectivist Newsletter
VOR: The Voice of Reason
VOS: The Virtue of Selfishness


ARI's version of the list

Craig Ceely's picture

Thanks. ARI's list is somewhat topically and alphabetically ordered, which some people might prefer (if you're looking for a specific item, for example).

I put it together my way because I wanted it in chronological order, the way it actually happened -- especially since there is so much material there, and since so many of the question and answer sessions are included. I'm glad others like it and I'm gratified by the comments, but I did it not because I thought the ARI page sucked, but because I wanted it organized the way I wanted to see it. And yes, I hope my annotations do help.

And I still think it's a pretty generous move on their part to have made so much of that stuff available.

Hugely Helpful

Kyrel Zantonavitch's picture

Craig -- I appreciate the hell out of your helpfully dated and annotated list! Smiling

Maybe you can send it to ARI (altho' I imagine they're far too slow-witted, inept, and socially hostile to improve their library list in such a user-friendly manner).

What's wrong with you people?

Richard Goode's picture

Craigslist.

Source materials

Craig Ceely's picture

Everything that I've been able to check matches versions which were published during Ayn Rand's lifetime, in other words, prior to the founding of ARI.

True and Reliable Source Material?

Kyrel Zantonavitch's picture

I hope to god this stuff isn't overly censored and altered. It would be nice if for once in their wretched, loathsome, slimy existence The Ayn Rand Institute didn't perpetrate egregious fraud.

Um yes...

Marcus's picture

"The Left certainly observes the Jewishness of capitalism, if not the atheistic."

And the Right certainly observes the Jewishness of Marxism. Can't win really, can they?

Also...

Craig Ceely's picture

I bought a paperback copy of Capitalism: The Unknown Ideal in Alexandria, Egypt, but I never saw an Ayn Rand book in Moscow, nor did I meet anyone who'd read or even heard of her. They could use it.

There's a Sheraton and a T.G.I. Friday's, and one of the world's largest McDonald's, and an Apple Store, all right there on Tverskaya ulitsa. Leading straight to Red Square. And a Bentley dealership, within a block or two from the former KGB headquarters. But no Ayn Rand that I could see.

There are problems...

Ross Elliot's picture

...Jewish hotspots in the US such as NYC, are Democratic, but I'm not enough of a scholar to see why. It may be that they see Democratic platforms such as religious freedom and general liberalism as being more important.

Jews have always been able to adapt for the purposes of survival, while maintaining influence. And NYC has always been the capital of realpolitik.

Still, I'll contend now that Rand suffers from racism. From Catholics, certainly. The Jews killed Jesus. Money changers in the Temple. All that bullshit. And since Catholicism is the mother religion, it flows through. Add in the Russian atheist, and you have the perfect storm.

Paul Ryan can do nothing else but reject her.

Well....

Craig Ceely's picture

I've heard Rand herself described as a Communist, so perhaps there we are.

I'm struck by something

Ross Elliot's picture

And I wonder is a certain racism is not involved here in the conservative rejection of her. Rand had a Russian accent and she was an atheist. The simple, conservative mind may align these two regardless of her support of capitalism

The Left certainly observes the Jewishness of capitalism, if not the atheistic.

But you can see this conflation of the Jew, the grasping capitalist Jew, and the atheist as being anathema to the faith-based raison of the conservative. It's double jeopardy.

Tremendous

Tom Burroughes's picture

This is absolutely fantastic, thanks very much for taking the time and the trouble to put this together. Much appreciated.

Smiling

Excellent links Craig!

Sandi's picture

Thank you Smiling

Thanks for pointing this out

Jason Quintana's picture

Thanks for pointing this out and doing a good job of putting everything into perspective. "Faith and Force" was one of the first Rand essays that I read, even before I read the Fountainhead and Atlas Shrugged. It didn't completely sink in at the time, but it laid the seeds. It is great to hear her deliver it in a speech. I didn't know that this existed.

Even more interesting for me is the Q&A session. Ayn Rand in her prime had a godlike intellect. She could answer questions and arguments with surgical precision. Her off the cuff verbal answers were better than most of us could accomplish in writing over the course of hours. As she got older she (understandably) got a little less precise and a little more irritable. None of those slight imperfections were present in the early 1960s.

well....

Craig Ceely's picture

Linz, Mark, Ross, thank you all for the kind words. This thing is not quite good enough.

Perhaps more in the next day or so. Jeez, something's got to be better than this.

Prime, Sir...

Ross Elliot's picture

...and well listed.

Cheers Craig

Mark Hubbard's picture

This is a great list.

Update

Craig Ceely's picture

Just to answer a few questions, reasonable and otherwise. Names and email addresses omitted to protect the daft.

1. Why chronological?

My response: Well, I'd always wanted to see it (that is, this stuff) presented it that way, and to read (or hear) and study it that way. I *wanted* it this way. But that option was never available before (well, not to me). Years after I'd discovered and read Ayn Rand, for example, I still hadn't been able to find, read, or hear "Faith and Force: The Destroyers of the Modern Word." Not anywhere. I'm no scholar myself, but I am the guy who proposed and conducted this interview, and I want to see certain presentations in the order they were created. For example, we have "there can be no unchosen obligations." Fine. But then I want to see subsequent remarks about subpoenas, jury duty, the metaphysical vs. the man-made, and more. And answers, if any.

2. The litigious types: in mentioning Apple, were you referring to The Beatles or to Steve Jobs?

Heh.

3. You ended a paragraph with "We had it tough." You wanted me/readers to be reminded of the Four Yorkshiremen sketch, I think.

Of course I did. I love that sketch.

4. Do you really see this as generosity on the part of the Ayn Rand Estate?

Yes. Don't you?

5. Why'd you do this?

Well, because I could. And see my response to the first question. And also, because you didn't do it.

Thanks for this Bro Ceely

Lindsay Perigo's picture

Extremely useful. I've blue-stickied it, and it can stay here for ever. Smiling

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.